As Australia accelerates its electric vehicle (EV) transition, a question is sparking heated debate: who should drive the creation of the charging network?
Victorian public utilities recently made a push into the EV charging market. But private charging companies are fighting back, arguing the move would result in unfair competition and stymie the growth of the private sector.
This battle highlights deeper questions of how best to boost EV charging while ensuring equitable access and affordable prices.
The Utility Case for Charging
Utilities argue they are well-suited to:
Upgrade the grid in coordination with new charging infrastructure
Deploy chargers quickly using existing rights-of-way and power assets
Reach underserved communities, like rural towns where private companies may see little profit
For governments, this can be appealing—utilities already have the scale and resources to roll out nationwide infrastructure.
The Case for Private Charging Operators
Private providers, however, argue that allowing utilities to dominate the market is anti-competitive. They are concerned that:
Utilities could cross-subsidize chargers with ratepayer money, under-pricing private providers
Innovation in the market would be dampened if utilities lock up infrastructure
Consumers may have fewer choices and more costly options in the future
This is the reason ring-fencing regulations in most nations prevent utilities from competing directly with private charging operators.
Why It's Important to EV Adoption
Australia's EV market is nascent but expanding rapidly. To reach adoption goals, Australia requires:
Extensive fast-charging corridors along long highway distances
Fair access in rural and suburban locations
Low costs to spur new purchasers
The debate boils down to this: should EV charging be a public utility, like electricity and water, or a competitive market service?
The Bottom Line
Australia's quandary mirrors global questions about EV charging: Who builds it? Who pays for it? Who makes money?
The answer may be a compromise—utilities putting in backbone infrastructure where it's most needed, with private operators competing and innovating in lucrative suburban and urban markets.
For drivers, the wish list is simple: more chargers, affordable rates, and a seamless experience no matter who is behind the plug.
Thinking about getting an EV charger for your business or home? Explore our curated selection of high-performance EV charging stations here.